All articles

A buyer's agent engagement priced at $25,000 should produce a written brief, comparable sales analysis on every property considered, off-market access where it exists, professional contract review, negotiation execution, and post-settlement support. The agents who deliver all of that earn the fee. The agents who deliver some of it are common. The agents who deliver almost none of it but charge the same fee are the reason buyer's agents have a mixed reputation.

This post walks the inside of a typical 90-day engagement, the deliverables that should appear at each stage, and the warning signs that the agent is taking your fee without the work.

The Fee Range In 2026#

Most investor engagements fall in the $20,000-$35,000 full-service range. Fee structure (fixed vs percentage) and refund/success terms matter as much as the headline number — see our choose right buyers agent guide for the engagement-structure rules.

Week 1-2: Briefing and Strategy#

The agent should produce a written brief covering:

• Investment objectives. Capital growth, yield, cash flow, or balanced.
• Target suburbs. Specific postcodes, with rationale (infrastructure, demographics, supply).
• Price band. Confirmed against the buyer's borrowing capacity and cash position.
• Property type. House vs unit vs townhouse, with reasoning.
• Timeline. Target settlement date.
• Risk tolerance. Specific scenarios the buyer is comfortable with versus would walk away from.

A genuine briefing takes 90 minutes minimum and produces a written 4-6 page document. If the agent skips this and goes straight to sending listings, the engagement is starting on shaky ground.

Red flag at this stage: Agent dismisses your stated objectives and pushes their preferred suburb without explanation.

Week 2-4: Initial Shortlists#

The agent should deliver shortlists with:

• 5-10 properties matching the brief, refreshed weekly
• Comparable sales analysis on each (last 3-5 sales in the same street or block)
• Specific data: median in suburb, vacancy rate, rental estimate, expected yield
• Site notes after physical inspection by the agent or their team
• Photographs that show the actual condition, not the sales agent's photos
• A clear "yes/no" recommendation on each property with reasoning

Red flag at this stage: Properties on the shortlist that the agent has not personally inspected.

Week 3-6: Off-Market and Pre-Market Opportunities#

Where the agent has genuine network access, off-market and pre-market opportunities should appear in this window. These are properties not yet publicly listed.

The agent should provide:

• Full address
• Asking price or price expectations
• Vendor circumstances (estate sale, divorce, relocation, etc. — relevant to negotiation)
• Specific timeline (when does the seller need to act, when goes to public listing)
• Comparable sales context

Red flag at this stage: Multiple "off-market" opportunities where the property is also visible on realestate.com.au.

Week 4-8: Inspections and Due Diligence#

For each shortlisted property the buyer commits to investigating:

• Building inspection (typically organised through the agent's preferred professional)
• Pest inspection
• Strata report (for units and townhouses)
• Title search and planning report (via conveyancer)
• Council records (any unapproved alterations, easements, plans)
• Rental appraisal from at least 2 property managers

Red flag at this stage: Agent skips physical inspection or proposes waiving conditions to win competitive bids.

Week 6-10: Negotiation and Offer#

The agent leads the negotiation strategy:

• Initial offer: typically 5-10% below asking, tested against comparables
• Counter-strategy mapped before negotiation begins
• Walk-away price confirmed with the buyer in writing
• Specific conditions to include (subject to finance, inspections, settlement timeline)

Red flag at this stage: Pressure to "move fast" without comparables to support the price.

Week 8-12: Contract and Exchange#

When agreement is reached:

• Contract review by both the agent and the buyer's conveyancer
• Specific clauses negotiated — settlement period, deposit amount, conditions
• Inclusions list verified
• Exchange execution

Red flag at this stage: Agent absent or unavailable during the contract review period.

Week 10-14: Settlement Support#

Between exchange and settlement:

• Final inspections coordinated
• Vendor's compliance with contract terms (any agreed repairs)
• Liaison with the buyer's bank and conveyancer
• Pre-settlement walkthrough attended

Red flag at this stage: Agent disengages after exchange and is unreachable during settlement issues.

Week 14+: Post-Settlement#

A good engagement includes:

• Property manager recommendations and introduction
• Quantity surveyor referral for depreciation schedule
• 30-day check-in on tenancy and any post-settlement issues
• 90-day review of property performance against expectations

Worked Example: $25,000 Engagement Outcome#

A Sydney investor engaged a Brisbane buyer's agent for a $25,000 fixed fee, search-and-buy structure. Brief: $850,000-$1,000,000 inner-Brisbane house with growth thesis.

Outcome at week 14:

• 12 weeks of weekly shortlists
• 4 inspections (3 public listings, 1 pre-market)
• 1 off-market opportunity that became the purchase
• Property purchased at $935,000 (vendor's asking $975,000 — $40,000 negotiation saving)
• Stamp duty saving on lower price: ~$1,100
• Estimated 5-year capital growth advantage of correctly chosen suburb vs investor's original DIY shortlist: $80,000+

Total quantifiable advantage to the investor: $40,000 negotiation + $1,100 duty + ~$15,000-$80,000 of suburb-selection growth advantage = $56,000-$120,000 against the $25,000 fee. The engagement returned 2-5x cost.

Where Engagements Fall Short#

Failure 1: Agent has only 1-2 truly off-market sources. The "off-market access" pitch is the headline value proposition. If the network is shallow, the engagement adds limited value beyond what a skilled DIY buyer could do.

Failure 2: Agent is paid by the developer too. Hidden conflicts of interest exist with some "buyer's agents" who also receive payments from new-build developers.

Failure 3: Agent rushes the briefing. A 30-minute phone call instead of a 90-minute briefing leads to mismatched expectations.

Failure 4: Agent uses one suburb for all clients. Some agents specialise so narrowly they can only work in one or two suburbs, regardless of the buyer's brief.

How To Run The Engagement#

Confirm your borrowing capacity and cash position before engaging — use the Borrowing Power Calculator and the Stamp Duty Calculator to lock down the price band and total cash needed. Take that brief to the agent as the starting point, not as a question.

Set quarterly review milestones in the engagement contract. If the agent has not delivered a viable shortlist by month 1 or a viable contract by month 3, the engagement should be reviewed and potentially terminated.

For the agent-selection criteria themselves, see our choose right buyers agent guide. For broader investment process, see our first investment property beginners guide.

Frequently Asked Questions#

Should the buyer's agent fee be paid before or after exchange?#

Most engagements split the fee — 30-50% on engagement, balance on exchange. Avoid full upfront payment; the agent's incentive to close drops sharply after they have collected the fee.

Can I negotiate the buyer's agent fee?#

Yes, particularly for higher-priced engagements or repeat clients. Fixed fees of $25,000+ have room for negotiation; smaller engagements typically less so.

What happens if the agent finds nothing in the engagement period?#

Depends on contract terms. Some engagements refund 50-100% of the search fee if no property is purchased; others refund nothing. Read the contract carefully before signing.

How do I verify the agent's track record?#

Ask for the last 10 transactions including addresses (post-settlement), prices paid, and dates. Cross-check against CoreLogic comparable sales. Ask for two client references — speak to them directly, not through the agent's curated testimonials.

Should I use a buyer's agent who is also a sales agent?#

Generally no. Dual-licensed practitioners face structural conflicts of interest. Some manage them well, but the cleaner path is engaging a pure buyer's representative whose only revenue comes from buyers.

Want to put these insights into action?

Presm gives you the tools to model, track, and grow your property portfolio with confidence.